By Mike Edwards
I still don’t know exactly how to describe God’s role with the Bible after I started rethinking why the Bible can’t be infallible or entirely inspired. It just seems so unlike God to control thoughts written down, rather than allowing us to grow in our understanding of God when ready. Scholars who respect Scriptures are admitting the Bible isn’t infallible. These same theologians are slow to suggest God didn’t inspire all of the Bible, which suggests God approves of everything written, but see concerns below. Many have been provoked to not even consider a relationship with God when sexist, homophobic, and genocidal behaviors attributed to God in the Bible are rationalized.
Why the Bible can’t be proven to be infallible.
The OT records thousands of times “God said…” Writers weren’t claiming God spoke audibly; they were simply writing about their “impressions” from God. We can’t prove such impressions were always right. It is circular logic to suggest the Bible is infallible or inspired because biblical writers make such a claim. Many who accept the Bible being infallible would not accept the Quran being infallible because it claims to be. God’s freedom-giving nature doesn’t support God performing a lobotomy on OT writers’ impressions of what they thought God was telling them.
But, even if God dictated all of the Bible words are still subject to interpretation. Forget the Older Testament. Scholars don’t agree what Jesus meant when talking about Hell. The fact that we disagree about the meaning of the same passages makes the discussion of the Bible’s infallibility a moot point because interpretations aren’t infallible. The formation of the Old Testament was a long, slow development over centuries. The Catholic Bible has seven additional books in the Old Testament than the Protestant Bible. We can’t know the books of the Bible we have were the ones God intended to convey truth or that other books haven’t been excluded to convey truth about God.
Why it is doubtful God inspired all of the Bible.
To describe the Bible as inspired or authoritative suggest to many that God approves of everything recording in the Bible. It is hard for most to believe God inspired hundreds of OT passages like I Samuel 15:3 when God told Israel: “Now go, attack the Amalekites… put to death men and women, children and infants, cattle and sheep, camels and donkeys.” Why would God inspire views that suggest God would endorse genocide? How could God inspire approving of a wife having her hand cut off when grabbing another’s man genitals protecting her husband (Deut. 25:11-12)?
There are good reasons to lean toward the Bible not being inspired because of certain morals attributed to God. An infallible or inspired view of Scriptures has led down the slippery slope of assuming interpretations are inspired. Not questioning if writers always understood God perfectly has led to justifying slavery, killing infidels, and other atrocities in the supposed name of God. Different opinions must stand side by side as we continually evaluate the most loving approach. God gave us a moral brain!
What is the Bible if not inspired by God?
The Bible is recorded experiences of beginnings with God and Israel culminating with the life of Jesus that we don’t possess in any other documents. Writings about God can keep us talking and reflecting what God is really like. God didn’t necessarily have in mind that recordings would not be questioned. The Bible claims to be God-breathe which can literally mean God-spirited (2 Tim. 3:16). Only the Old Testament existed when these words penned. This passage could simply mean God uses writings about God to touch our spirit.
Certainty in God isn’t the Holy Grail!
An inspired Bible leads to interpretations magically becoming infallible. Believing such a Book exists has led to condemning gays in God’s name, though those who accept Scriptures as authoritative don’t agree the Bible disapproves of homosexuality. A fallible Book can’t hide behind infallible interpretations. Uncertainty doesn’t have to led to chaos as moral laws that violate the rights of others are obvious. The majority of people born in this world never read a Bible but seem to have an inborn knowledge of right and wrong, hinting a Creator not a Book communicates to all what is good.
How can we read the Bible?
Read the Bible reflectively than for solutions to specific problems. Read the Bible with an open-mind motivated by love. Jesus didn’t always answer questions directly because circumstances vary and the issue is our heart in solving problems. Can you imagine a world where all looked out for the interests of others and not just themselves when facing difficulties? Don’t check your moral conscience at the door as you consider what a loving God is really like. As long as we read the Bible with a questioning spirit rather than blind obedience, it seems the Bible can continue to influence millions to live a more selfless life.
For related questions about the Bible go to:
http://what-god-may-really-be-like.com/rethinking-the-bible/
Done with Religion 
Thanks so much J for your openness. We are in the same boat having been in “infallible” circles for years. I just want to have an open discussion because that is how we can learn, but such groups struggle to agree to disagree. I get it since I had the same actions years ago. It seems infallibility is a slippery slope toward dogmatism despite there not being total agreement among those who believe in the infallibility of the Bible. We just have to remain dependent on God and hope for relationships that aren’t legalistic.
LikeLiked by 1 person
This just messes with my mind so much! Having been in “the Word is infallible” groups for decades, it’s such a twist to realize the things you are expressing here are valid. And I surely can’t discuss much of it with anyone I know. They tend to get rather offended. It’s so startling to realize how much man has influenced all we’ve been raised to believe, as well as all the rituals we called “church”. I always appreciate your posts.
LikeLiked by 1 person
The first thing a follower of the Way should do is remove the old covenants from the New Covenant. Example: Some say baptism is a work, yet they follow the old law for the tithe, the clergy, and the sabbath. When we follow the simple commands of Jesus in Obedience to His commands we don’t need the traditions, rituals, reverends, popes, and rules of men added since the first church of Acts.
LikeLiked by 1 person